Sherlock holmes which movie is best

Wato, which means she's called Wato-san, and that's just perfection. The combined might of the iconic nature of the character and Robert Downey Jr. The series plays with the idea of Sherlock as a more physical hero than previous incarnations in case you doubt that this was released in and directed by Guy Richie , Sherlock does parkour at the very beginning of the film. But there's support for that idea within the actual text — in the very first Conan Doyle story, "A Study in Scarlet," Watson notes that his new roommate "is an expert singlestick player, boxer, and swordsman.

There's a world of difference between Downey Jr. There were two contemporary Sherlock TV shows running simultaneously for a good part of the s, and Jonny Lee Miller doesn't get nearly enough credit for finding his own spin on the character while also surviving the incredible physical and mental demands that come with making a CBS procedural drama.

As of writing, there have been a total of 13 feature-length installments of Sherlock made — Elementary 's seven-season run lasted episodes.

Beyond its longevity, Miller's version is notable for the twists its initial premise makes on the original tale, especially the way it centers the character's addiction issues, beginning with a Sherlock fresh out of rehab and a Dr. Watson who comes to live with him as a sober companion. For the record, if I were to make the Watson equivalent of this list in the future, Lucy Liu would be a serious contender for the number one slot.

This is a more vulnerable Holmes than others, but one who proves easier to emphasize with, all without him losing that essential brilliant spark. For at least one generation, arguably more, Basil Rathbone was the definitive Sherlock Holmes, calm and inscrutable and always capable of solving the case. One of the more prolific actors to play the role, starring in 14 films over a seven-year period first for 20th Century Fox, then for Universal Pictures , what stands out about his portrayal is that the character always seems to take a backseat to the mystery being solved — perhaps because Rathbone didn't seem to like him very much.

While he fully acknowledges in that quote how his perspective might be affected by proximity, it still explains why Rathbone's solid and steady work lacks the spark of other portrayals.

That being said, the man is iconic for a reason. There's a range of Sherlock types on this list, from the unconventional to the more traditional, and of the traditional options available Jeremy Brett is simply top of his class. As the star of 41 different mysteries produced by Granada Television, Brett delivers the intellectual swagger and wry wit found in the best interpretations.

But what sets him apart from the others is the ever-present sense of humanity he brings to the character. Any iconic character with over years of legacy is painfully easy to turn into caricature, but with his time on screen, Brett found a way to keep alive the idea of Holmes as a man not just with a brilliant brain, but a human heart. And he did so while acting in some of the most faithful Conan Doyle adaptations to date, ensuring his place in history as one of the very best and most beloved Sherlocks to date.

The fun thing about writing a list like this is knowing, from my own experience as a reader, that you've been counting down this whole time to see what won the top slot. Maybe you even skipped directly here from the top of the article? Who's to say. Tweekums 23 January Having recently enjoyed the BBC series 'Sherlock' I thought it was a good time to watch this film adaptation; it is safe to say they are very different!

Here Sherlock is a man of action just as much as he is an intellectual. In the adventure that follows Holmes and Watson must figure out what Blackwood's ultimate aim is and then prevent him from achieving it in order to save the country.

The situation is made even more confused by the arrival of Irene Adler, an old acquaintance of Holmes who is now in the employment of the man destined to become Holmes greatest foe. This film took things far less seriously than the television series but that doesn't mean it wasn't entertaining; in fact it was a romp from start to finish. The action was impressive with Holmes and Watson getting in numerous scrapes and narrowly surviving an explosion and death at the hands of an enormous Frenchman!

It is nice to see director Guy Richie moving away from his regular gangster films as he has brought something new to Holmes and made a film that is exciting, amusing and suitably for adults and all but the youngest children. It's a good film inspired on splendid novels about Sherlock Holmes character written by Arthur Conan Doyle , including two first-range nasties with malignant aims as Mark Strong as Blackwood and Doctor Moriarty , furthermore one woman , Rachel McAdams , as a suspicious young with mysterious purports.

In the flick appears the usual of the Arthur Conan Doyle's novels : Dr. Holmes along Watson will solve unanswered mysteries and Sherlock undergoes some risked experiences to resolve the cases using even his habitual disguise. It's a nice Holmes film with gripping London and sensational setting.

A genuine ripping yarn very intriguing. The movie blends suspense , thriller , detective action , cloak and dagger , mystery and is pretty interesting. It packs an exciting amount of surprises with great lots of entertainment. This is a classy and effective romp with a strongly casting. Robert Downey as Holmes plays in a clever , broody and impetuous manner , as whimsical detective is top notch , he's in cracking form acting as a two-fisted fighter.

He makes an unique perspective on his life revealing a complex personality. He's finely matched in battle of wits with Blackwood-Mark Strong. The stars have a splendid fight towards the end on the Tower of London , plus Holmes tries to battle against his arch-enemy Moriarty but with an amazing final surprise. Although Basil Rathbone will be forever identified as Holmes , however Sherlock is also played by Robert Downey as an intelligent , cunning , broody and impetuous pipesmoking sleuth but addicted to the cocaine.

Watson here isn't a bumbling and botcher pal generally represented by Nigel Bruce but an clever and astute partner perfectly incarnated by Jude Law.

The film has a creepy atmosphere , it's in glimmer color with lights and shades that originate strange setting. Set design is of first rate , the movie is very atmospheric , the dark , shady and dirty slums of London are very well designed but with excessive use of computer generator images. Screenwriter Michael Johnson provides the original plot , creating the basis for this particularly storyline. The film boasts a beautifully cinematography by Philippe Rousselot and a haunting score by Hans Zimmer in John Barry style.

This big budgeted production by Joel Silver sparkles with polish and wit and the ending is as exciting as moving and being well directed by Guy Ritchie. As expected, this 21st century reinvention of Conan Doyle's great detective bears very little resemblance to any previous movie incarnation, Downey Jr. Seeing the usually dapper detective and the equally eminent doctor portrayed in such manner is hard to come to terms with, but wasn't a deal-breaker for me—I can appreciate a new spin on an old theme—but the asinine script and unnecessarily flashy direction sadly was.

An illogical, plot-hole ridden piece of guff, the film is peppered with juvenile humour and heavily stylised action set-pieces in a desperate effort to try and detract from the many weaknesses and flaws in the narrative, which start with a highly implausible fake execution and become more and more strained as the movie progresses.

As a piece of mindless popcorn nonsense, I guess this fares no worse than many a modern Hollywood blockbuster, but as a case for the finest crime-busting mind the world has ever known, it's far from brilliant.

I enjoyed it, but not as much as I was hoping to. TxMike 4 May Since it is a Guy Richie film I was expecting it to be wild and different, and there I wasn't disappointed. Much in the way I was not disappointed with "Snatch. Maybe it came across as a bit too cartoonish, over the top.

Still, Robert Downey Jr. Although I found that he tried a bit too hard to sound authentic British and some of his mumbling was difficult to understand. Jude Law was his faithful assistant Dr. John Watson, and their partnership on screen worked well, I thought. Mark Strong is an actor that I am not particularly familiar with, although I now realize I have seen some movies he was in, but here he is excellent as Lord Blackwood, who it seems is using ancient magic to gain power.

His ambition is high, to eventually re-take that colony, now known as the USA. The story devolves into Holmes and Watson figuring out how to defeat Blackwood and to stem the tide of killings Blackwood is responsible for. The film used an editing technique that really added something.

Holmes was, among other things, an expert at fighting. So a couple of times when he was about to pull some fast-action fighting moves we saw in very slow motion what he was about to do, as it was described in his own voice, then we saw the actual moves in fast motion.

I like that technique. Quinoa 27 December Sherlock Holmes has been done and revisited and re-baked so many times one wonder what else could be done with it my first exposure wasn't even to Holmes directly but through Disney's Great Mouse Detective. So it was about time, I suppose, that Hollywood would tackle this as any other franchise and make it into a big smashing action movie But luckily Guy Ritchie, making his first real step into a big studio situation not his crime movies or misguided Madonna-inspired pics is a success on a basic level: he gets audiences interested in the Sherlock Holmes detective story first, as well as the rapport between Holmes and Watson, and then lays in his own touches to the material.

It's another of those stories that, oddly enough like Great Mouse Detective, is as simple a plan as a villain's plot could get: take over England. In this case we have Lord Blackwood nefariously cold performance from Mark Strong , who it would appear has been practicing dark magic, and has killed five people.

He's hanged, but it also appears that he has risen from the grave and puts forth a dastardly plot to "change the course of the world", as a villain like him would put it so bluntly, and it's up to Holmes to stop him. While figuring out what's going on in the story, the detective work of it all, is fascinating, it's not entirely the true draw of the film.

If there's any invention in the plot it's in the ways that Blackwood uses confounded technology from a turn of the 20th century period that works on a level that's fresh for audiences. No, it's Robert Downey Jr and, also, Jude Law as Holmes and Watson, watching them on screen interacting with each other, interacting with others, and figuring out what's going to happen next mostly this is Holmes, and nine times out of them he figures it out in an instant and spends most of his time explaining it away, accompanied by visuals , that makes it most compelling.

Downey couldn't be more equipped to play a character like this, and like Iron Man it's a character that has more nuance and more going on under the surface than we might think looking at him. There's snark, there's sarcasm, there's a bad-ass bravura and a sense of entitlement to both characters, but in Holmes we see Downey minus the coke habit of the original Doyle creation for a PG rated film tackle this iconic figure with the intelligence and grace found in previous versions, but his own spin on it as well.

And Law is up to the challenge of Watson, even if, arguably, the roles could be reversed for the stars and played just as well. The action set-pieces are good But all in all Ritchie gives a lot of the fights and action real excitement and energy; my favorite was Holmes, in an act of clairvoyance for the audience's sake, shows what he'll do in slow-motion and narration to an opponent in a bare-knuckle brawl, and then just does it in regular-speed film.

It's a creative angle on it without going too predictable. Oh, and did I mention the music is just about perfect here? Listening to the few songs, and most notably the old-time charged Hans Zimmer score, adds pep and inspiration to a lot of scenes, the twang of the guitar or violins and other instruments usual to find in a blockbuster, but a welcome treat.

Sherlock Holmes is fun times, a kind of one-shot graphic novel turned into a movie that deviates from prior times with the books and stories, and still works as entertainment. It's not high-art. It's Robert Downey Jr. Thrilling, intellectual and adrenaline fuelled adventure Gordon 1 January This film is about Sherlock Holmes and his close ally Dr Watson solving the plot of a maniacal mastermind who wanted to control United Kingdom through fear and dark magic.

The way Sherlock Holmes solves crime is engagingly told. How he observes and deduces is simply amazing. The scene where he deduces so much about Mary is astonishing and entertainingly told at the same time. The crime solving is very intellectual, and there area also many fight scenes to keep the adrenaline up.

The plot is great as well. It is so engaging and thrilling, it keeps me on edge or gasping due to fear so many times. I really enjoyed watching "Sherlock Holmes". Guy Ritchie transforms Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's stoic and methodical super sleuth into a scruffy, rough and tough detective; not exactly the great Basil Rathbone. The cycle consists of five films 11 runs total of minutes. These films have brought a very significant contribution to the development of the image of Sherlock Holmes in the global film and I do not understand why they are not even mentioned here.

After all, if they drew the attention of the British Queen, then it is that — it means. Please forgive me, if somewhere — that is not the correct word, because I used a translator. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed. Content, tone, setting, budget and target audience all vary but for film buffs there are at least three, possibly two actors, who seem to constantly jostle for the top screen portrayal of Holmes — a discussion this list of 10 Sherlock Holmes Films You Must See will doubtless fuel all the more — the game is afoot… They Might be Giants An interesting addition to the list as the lead character, a widowed millionaire, played by George C.

Basil the Great Mouse Detective Possibly a controversial entry to the list for some but this Disney animation from has much to recommend it. Pages: 1 2.

Comments 10 best Sherlock Holmes movies. Finch says: Reply March 20, at am. CaseX says: Reply March 20, at pm. Veronica Clarke says: Reply March 26, at am. Koolz says: Reply April 24, at pm. Sherlock Holmes says: Reply July 31, at pm. Cyril Veakspey says: Reply August 8, at am. Relocated to Tokyo, the newest title on this list also features one of the sexiest incarnations of Sherlock to date.

Returning to Japan from volunteering in Syria, Dr. The first images of Sherlock in her tan trench, stilettos, and swaggering stance are hard not to be attracted to. The final two seasons? It was hard to hear them over the sound of my extended sigh. Just as he did when helming Doctor Who , producer, writer, and co-creator Steven Moffat contorts his Holmes and Watson into increasingly complicated and absurd storylines.

But what keeps this show at No. The show itself feels the most full of all Sherlock Holmes adaptations, with details and staging that bring its Victorian setting to life. For faithfulness to its source material and the spirit of the work, this adaptation is hard to beat.

As a bonus, the foley work and sound engineering of these adaptations have a hypnotic ASMR crispness. I watched this adaptation for the first time recently, and it is absolutely bonkers. The movie opens with a rather hedonistic retelling of the Baskerville legend, complete with its hound from hell.

Care warning for attempted sexual assault. The production values have the campy flair of other horror movies from Hammer Films, like The Curse of Frankenstein.